Rubric

Lesson 1

Debate

Rubric scores: Incomplete (1) - Partially proficient (2) - Proficient (3) - Exemplary (4)

Content

Incomplete (1): limited relevance and evidence; basic arguments with minimal depth.
Partially proficient (2): some relevance and evidence; surface-level arguments with a few insightful points.
Proficient (3): relevant content with good evidence; considered and well-structured arguments.
Exemplary (4): highly relevant content with strong, compelling evidence; deep, insightful arguments.

Delivery & language

Incomplete (1): unclear articulation; basic language use; difficult pronunciation.
Partially proficient (2): generally clear delivery; adequate language use; understandable pronunciation.
Proficient (3): clear articulation; good language use; good pronunciation.
Exemplary (4): crystal clear delivery; excellent language use; perfect pronunciation.

Structure & organization

Rebuttal & responsiveness

Incomplete (1): ineffective rebuttals; poor responsiveness to points made by others.
Partially proficient (2): some effective rebuttals; responds to some points.
Proficient (3): effective rebuttals; good responsiveness to opposing points.
Exemplary (4): very effective and well-structured rebuttals; fully responsive and engaging with opposing points.

Comprehension

Incomplete (1): limited understanding of questions and comments.
Partially proficient (2): understands most questions and comments.
Proficient (3): good understanding, including some nuances of the debate.
Exemplary (4): fully comprehends all aspects of the debate, including subtle nuances.

Presentation: AI case study

Rubric scores: Incomplete (1) - Partially proficient (2) - Proficient (3) - Exemplary (4)

Content

Incomplete (1): limited or irrelevant content; lacks a comprehensive understanding of the case study.
Partially proficient (2): some relevant content; basic understanding of the case study with a few insightful points.
Proficient (3): relevant and comprehensive content; clear understanding of the case study and its complexities.
Exemplary (4): in-depth and insightful content; demonstrates a thorough understanding of the case study with advanced insights.

Understanding & Analysis

Incomplete (1): lacks understanding and analysis of the ethical dilemmas; superficial or no perspectives.
Partially proficient (2): basic understanding and analysis; some perspectives on the ethical dilemmas.
Proficient (3): good understanding and analysis; clear perspectives on the ethical dilemmas.
Exemplary (4): excellent understanding and analysis; deep, insightful perspectives on the ethical dilemmas.

Solution Framework

Incomplete (1): solution framework is unclear, unfeasible, or missing.
Partially proficient (2): basic solution framework; somewhat feasible but lacks depth in technological, ethical, societal, and legal aspects.
Proficient (3): well-structured solution framework; addresses technological, ethical, societal, and legal aspects.
Exemplary (4): comprehensive and innovative solution framework; thoroughly addresses all aspects including technological, ethical, societal, and legal perspectives.

Presentation Skills

Incomplete (1): unclear, incoherent presentation; lacks structure.
Partially proficient (2): somewhat clear and coherent; basic structure.
Proficient (3): clear, coherent, and well-structured presentation.
Exemplary (4): highly engaging, coherent, and excellently structured presentation.

Digital poster: AI fair

Rubric scores: Incomplete (1) - Partially proficient (2) - Proficient (3) - Exemplary (4)

Content and relevance

Incomplete (1): limited or irrelevant content; lacks a clear focus on a specific aspect of AI's future.
Partially proficient (2): some relevant content; basic focus on a specific aspect of AI's future.
Proficient (3): relevant and focused content; clear depiction of a specific aspect of AI's future.
Exemplary (4): highly relevant, in-depth content; insightful and innovative focus on a specific aspect of AI's future.

Creativity and originality

Incomplete (1): lacks creativity; very basic or generic ideas.
Partially proficient (2): some creative elements; but remains somewhat generic.
Proficient (3): creative and original ideas; poster shows uniqueness in concept.
Exemplary (4): highly creative and original; poster demonstrates unique, innovative thinking

Impact on society or employment

Incomplete (1): no clear explanation of AI's impact on society or employment.
Partially proficient (2): basic explanation of AI's potential impact.
Proficient (3): clear and thoughtful explanation of AI's impact on society or employment.
Exemplary (4): in-depth and insightful explanation of AI's significant impact on society or employment.

Use of digital tools

Incomplete (1): ineffective or no use of digital tools for poster creation.
Partially proficient (2): basic use of digital tools; lacks sophistication in design.
Proficient (3): good use of digital tools; the design demonstrates skillful application.
Exemplary (4): excellent use of digital tools; the design is professional and demonstrates advanced skills.